Return to parker-films.com
THE FIRST LAS VEGAS • HISTORY YOU DIDN'T KNOW
Billy the Kid’s Deal with the Governor
A secret night meeting in Lincoln, and an offer the law never honored.
- DATE
- March 17, 1879
- PLACE
- Squire Wilson’s house, Lincoln, N.M.
- GOVERNOR
- Lew Wallace, 1878–1881
The Hook
On the night of March 17, 1879, the governor of New Mexico Territory sat down in secret with the most wanted young outlaw in the West and made him an offer. Governor Lew Wallace wrote that he had authority to exempt Billy the Kid from prosecution if he testified about a murder he had witnessed. Billy delivered. The protection never came.
It is the same year as The First Las Vegas, and it explains the Billy who walks into Doc’s parlor: a kid who already knows exactly what the law’s word is worth.
Billy kept his end of the bargain. The territory did not.
What Happened
- A drunken peace parley in Lincoln ends with Billy Campbell and Jimmy Dolan killing the one-armed lawyer Huston Chapman in the street. Billy watches it happen.
- Wallace receives Billy’s first letter, offering to testify against Chapman’s killers if his own indictments are set aside.
- Wallace writes back: come alone to Squire John B. Wilson’s house in Lincoln, and tell no one.
- The secret night meeting. Wallace lays out the plan: a staged arrest, protective custody, grand jury testimony, then freedom. Billy asks for the same deal for his friend Tom O’Folliard.
- Jesse Evans and Billy Campbell escape from Fort Stanton, and Billy now fears being murdered before he can testify.
- Billy testifies before the grand jury. Dolan and Campbell are indicted for Chapman’s murder.
- Wallace’s ally Ira Leonard warns him that District Attorney William Rynerson, a Dolan friend tied to the Santa Fe Ring, is set on prosecuting Billy anyway.
- Billy and O’Folliard quietly walk out of custody. Wallace has turned back to finishing Ben-Hur.
- In Las Vegas, “Dirty Dave” Rudabaugh kills jailer Lino Valdez during a failed attempt to break J.J. Webb out of jail. Las Vegas does not forget.
- Pat Garrett’s posse captures Billy, Rudabaugh and others at Stinking Springs.
- Passing through Fort Sumner, Billy says goodbye to Paulita Maxwell.
- The Las Vegas depot. As Garrett loads his prisoners onto the Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe train for Santa Fe, a mob surrounds it, determined to take Rudabaugh for the jailer’s murder. Garrett unchains Billy and Rudabaugh and arms them to help protect him and his deputies from the mob. The standoff lasts about half an hour. A Las Vegas Gazette reporter interviews Billy on the platform and writes that he longed to be set free and armed to fight on the side of his captors. The train pulls out, and Billy tips his hat with an “Adios.”
- Jailed in Santa Fe, Billy writes Wallace for help. The Las Vegas Gazette asks Wallace about clemency, and he refuses.
- Pat Garrett kills Billy at Fort Sumner, in the house of Pete Maxwell, Paulita Maxwell’s brother.
- New Mexico Governor Bill Richardson declines a posthumous pardon, citing the historical ambiguity over why Wallace reneged.
In Their Own Words
I have authority to exempt you from prosecution if you will testify to what you say you know.Gov. Lew Wallace, to Billy, March 1879
I am not afraid to die like a man fighting but I would not like to be killed like a dog unarmed.William H. Bonney, to Wallace, March 1879
I can’t see how a fellow like him should expect any clemency from me.Gov. Lew Wallace, Las Vegas Gazette, 1881
Why It Matters for the Show
The deal gives Billy a wound the audience can see: he did everything the law asked, and the law used him and moved on.
- Billy’s motive. He comes into Doc’s parlor already knowing a badge’s word is worth nothing. That makes his grin on the depot platform read as contempt, not just bravado.
- A mirror for Doc and Kate. Kate builds her committee on documentation and legal process. Billy is living proof of what happens when the paper process is owned by the Santa Fe Ring.
- Wallace becomes a real character. The governor who wrote Billy’s exemption letter is the same man finishing Ben-Hur in Santa Fe while Las Vegas burns: the law on paper, far from the plaza.
- A Las Vegas thread. Wallace’s refusal of clemency ran in the Las Vegas Gazette, a paper the show already draws on.
- The dentist visit. A bad tooth and a girl to impress get Billy into Doc’s chair. The broken deal gives Doc something real to talk to him about while he works.
Documented vs. Dramatized
The meeting and the letters are on the record. Whether Wallace promised a full pardon, or only immunity from prosecution, is still argued.
| ON THE RECORD | DEBATED | DRAMATIZED IN THE SHOW |
|---|---|---|
| Billy’s letters to Wallace and Wallace’s reply | Whether “exempt you from prosecution” meant a full pardon | Billy’s dental visit to Doc |
| The March 17, 1879 meeting in Lincoln | Whether Wallace ever meant to follow through | Paulita Maxwell as the girl he wants to impress |
| Billy’s grand jury testimony, April 1879 | Holliday and Bonney meeting in Las Vegas | All dialogue |
| Wallace’s refusal of clemency in the Las Vegas Gazette | “Who wants to die for my freedom?” | |
| The December 27, 1880 depot standoff over Rudabaugh, Garrett unchaining and arming Billy and Rudabaugh against the mob, and Billy’s Gazette interview | ||
| Richardson declining a pardon in 2010 |
From the Record
True West Magazine
The Chapman murder, Billy’s letters, and the Wilson house meetingAssociated Press, December 31, 2010
New Mexico governor declines to pardon Billy the KidLegends of America
Dave Rudabaugh, the Dodge City Gang and the jailer’s killingFurther reading
Robert Utley, Billy the Kid: A Short and Violent Life (1989); Frederick Nolan, The West of Billy the Kid (1998); Mark Lee Gardner, To Hell on a Fast Horse (2009).Archival & Historical Provenance — full source documentation available on record by request — [email protected]
Lookbook & full script by request: parker-films.com/contact.html
PARKER FILMS LLC | [email protected] | parker-films.com | © 2026